Does the Cabbage Soup Diet Really Work? Risks and Facts
The cabbage soup diet is a short-term plan, usually 5 to 7 days, in which most meals are replaced with a low-calorie vegetable soup. The claim that you can lose about 4.5 kg (10 lb) a week is repeated often, but most of that loss is water and some muscle, not fat.
Don't just read it, track itSnap a photo of your meal and Kalorita logs calories and macros in seconds. 3 days free.→How the cabbage soup diet works
In a typical version, the soup replaces the main meals of the day. Some plans add a small amount of fruit or vegetables. Sources usually suggest limiting the diet to 5 to 7 days, never going beyond 10 days, and waiting at least 14 days before repeating it. Drinking 1.5 to 2 liters of water a day and taking short walks are common advice.
This structure fits the category of crash diets covered in our shock diet article: a sharp, short-term calorie cut that is not meant to be kept up long term.
Is the claimed weight loss realistic?
One kilogram of body fat stores roughly 7,700 kcal of energy. If 4.5 kg a week came entirely from fat, you would need a daily deficit of about 4,950 kcal. That is several times the energy needs of a typical adult, and it cannot be reached with a low-calorie soup.
Most of the weight lost on such diets is water and glycogen, the carbohydrate stored in muscle and liver along with water, plus some muscle tissue. When normal eating resumes, the water returns quickly. To compare your own needs with a realistic deficit, try our calorie deficit calculator.
Each gram of glycogen is stored with about 3 grams of water. That is why any diet that sharply cuts carbohydrates shows a fast drop on the scale in the first days. The drop is not fat loss. It is the stores emptying, and they refill as soon as carbohydrates return.
Calories in the soup: the recipe changes everything
According to USDA FoodData Central values, a cabbage soup made without added fat has roughly 20 to 40 kcal per 100 g. That low number is why the diet lowers the scale in the short term. Recipes that add butter, stock or cream rise quickly, so the diet has no single fixed calorie value.
Low calorie does not make the diet safe or sustainable. Relying on one food group (vegetables and liquid) can lead to protein and vitamin gaps over time. For a more balanced approach, see our weight loss meal plan article, which has gram and calorie examples.
Who should not try it
- People with chronic conditions: diabetes, kidney disease or heart disease. Talk to your doctor before starting any restrictive plan.
- Pregnant or breastfeeding women: energy and nutrient needs rise in these stages, so a single-food-group diet is not advised.
- Regular exercisers: low protein can slow muscle repair after training. Our article on fast weight loss diets explains why these methods are not recommended for athletes.
Common cabbage soup diet versions and time limits
There is no single recipe. The vegetable used and the time limit change from source to source. The table compares four versions that appear most often.
| Version | Suggested length | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Cabbage soup diet | 7 days at most | The most common version; should not be repeated without a 14-day break |
| Zucchini soup diet | 10 days at most | Often promoted as a detox |
| Beetroot soup diet | 1 week | Some sources claim 3 kg in a week, but their basis is unclear |
| Yogurt soup diet | No clear limit in most sources | Not recommended for people with chronic conditions |
Protein and micronutrient gaps
The biggest weakness of the soup diet is protein. A vegetable soup usually provides only 2 to 5 g of protein per serving, far below typical adult needs. Check your own target with our protein needs calculator. Low protein has been linked to muscle loss, hair shedding and a weaker immune system.
Unless the soup includes meat, chicken or beans, vitamin B12, iron and zinc are largely missing. The effects of these gaps can become more noticeable after about 7 days.
Frequently asked questions
How many days should the cabbage soup diet last?
Common guidance is 5 to 7 days. Most sources say not to go beyond 10 days, and to take at least 14 days off before repeating it.
Does the cabbage soup diet really lose 10 lb a week?
That figure comes from popular sources and is not supported by scientific research. Even if that much is lost, most of it is water and glycogen, not fat.
Can I eat anything else on the diet?
Some plans allow a limited amount of vegetables or fruit alongside the soup, but the core rule is that the soup replaces your meals.
Does the cabbage soup diet cause muscle loss?
It can. Low calories and low protein mean some of the weight lost can come from muscle tissue.
Will the weight come back after I stop?
Most of the early loss is water, so it usually returns quickly once you eat normally.
Is there a safer alternative?
A moderate calorie deficit that includes enough protein and a variety of foods is considered both safer and more sustainable.
Does adding chicken or meat to the soup ruin the diet?
No. It adds protein and iron, which fills some of the gaps. It also adds calories and salt, so keep those in mind.
Make calorie tracking simple
Take a photo of your food and Kalorita's AI estimates its calories and macros in seconds.
Download free